Cargo-web support?

[mvlabat]

💡 Feature description

Some crates may require using cargo-web to build. For example, stdweb.
Will it make sense to detect if cargo-web is installed and use it for compiling projects?

[ashleygwilliams]

@mvlabat - this project was primarily created to support the wasm-bindgen use case, but to the extent that it's not overly complicating i would definitely be interested in exploring supporting stdweb as well!

if you'd like- if you could comment here with what you'd imagine the plan for integrating stdweb, we can discuss here and decide if it makes sense! i'm certainly not opposed, and i think it'd be exciting to get it to work!

[mvlabat]

@ashleygwilliams, thanks for the answer and your open position about this!

An argument for doing it (though maybe not a very strong one) is that wasm-pack is used in some workflows utilizing JS building tools. Don't know about Webpack ecosystem, but Parcel, for instance, has such plugin: https://github.com/catsigma/parcel-plugin-wasm.rs. It detects if wasm-pack is installed on user's system and if so it uses it as a default build instrument for compiling Rust dependencies.
So the point is that this feature could bring cargo-web support to JS bulding tools (supporting wasm-pack) probably without any effort.

I think that one way of implementing this could be just to detect if Web.toml exists for a project. Or, if a user doesn't have any configuration, they could use some special CLI attribute that tells wasm-pack to use cargo-web binary.

Btw - about the wasm-bindgen use case - I've just stumbled upon this issue: koute/cargo-web#92. It seems that exactly this use case is not currently possible. :)

[alexcrichton]

I personally think that the way forward here is koute/stdweb#318, not having wasm-pack delegate to cargo web. The issue runs much deeper in terms of library configuration and such, and having a unified story would allow us to reap many more benefits!

[fitzgen]

I agree that koute/stdweb#318 is the best way to unify. I think trying to wrap cargo web would just add more maintenance burden and should become unnecessary relatively quickly.

[ashleygwilliams]

now that koute/stdweb#318 has landed - i think we can close this. are there any outstanding todos?