Skip to content

🔨 Moving towards MVP Milestone 1 #87

Closed
@shadowspawn

Description

I feel like we are close to having a decent MVP version with a (close to) zero-config parse-anything mode with predictable behaviours, and a strict mode that detects many common user errors so the author does not have to.

We are at risk of stalling though. @darcyclarke who did the initial proposal in this repo is currently doing his own thing in https://github.com/darcyclarke/minargs (taking into account some discussions here), and I think @bcoe is taking a break from trying to coax some consensus (he did mention threads with "4 people with 8 opinions in them" as annoying, but good!). I suspect also the wider tooling group who are behind this initiative have been busy elsewhere.

I have been leaving it up to common agreement, or Benjamin to move things forward. We have covered a lot of good ground in discussions, but there are multiple viewpoints and goals and desires. I am going to try being more active to push towards a first milestone with key functionality implemented while we have people engaged here. Potentially with some approach rather than a universally agreed approach. It doesn't mean it is ready for Node.js consideration, or everything it could be, but I would like to try for something reasonably solid and implemented and usable.

I'll put 🔨 in any comments where I am pushing for a way forward. Speak up if I am out of order on a decision or process, and I'll cease and desist. 🙊

(Disclaimer: I am a maintainer of Commander. When issues come up I often research what other libraries are doing and what the POSIX and GNU guidelines say. I believe I have solid knowledge and experience of how command line parsing works in practice. I don't have experience with building a parser on top of a parser as such, which although not one of the stated goals of this repo is definitely of interest to people!)

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions