-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 66
Planner Closed items should be hidden #4480
Comments
@joshuawilson i see this already - there's a Show Completed checkbox which is not checked by default. Thus as soon as I change the state to Closed, it is hidden. |
Maybe that only works for the |
Nope, doesn't work there either. I don't know what it is supposed to do but it doesn't hide closed items. |
@serenamarie125 what do you think about a permanent filter or tab that has the |
From @rootAvish
|
@serenamarie125 @joshuawilson I just confirmed, 'Show Completed' checkbox does hide closed items even in the iteration view. But if the tree view is enabled, it might still show the parent item that has been closed. |
After a brief discussion @joshuawilson and I figured the following bugs in the implementation: |
@Veethika earlier we had limited no. of status and this was our proposal: Later there was need of more no. of status and we took the decision to takeout all the icons from the status, I also suggested to take out the generic icon which they are using right now (without consulting UX team), because it make no sense at all. In particular, to show the WI closed the only indication was to look at the status column. |
@Veethika correct. Work item Closed work item is not visible only if
It is our current implemetation. |
@sahil143 @vikram-raj IMO if a work-item doesn't have a child that matches the filter, it's shouldn't appear in the result set at all. The only purpose of showing the closed WIs while the tree view enabled is to avoid breaking the tree structure. A sibling WIs status shouldn't be considered while surfacing closed items. Is there any other reasoning that I'm probably missing out on? @sunilmalagi There's a difference in type treatment in the screenshot attached above. Some appear bold and others light. Are you aware of the intention behind that? Can we make the closed items appear different than the others? |
@sunilmalagi @joshuawilson @serenamarie125
|
Closed work items are displayed based on certain conditions. If a parent work item matches a criteria, all the children, closed and open ones, are displayed.
We need to change this to a feature request. Also, we can focus on the Closed Work Item behaviour under the Query tab. |
Based on a conversation held on 2019-Jan-04 including Dev, PM and UX, the UX team will not be providing support for planner items. Removing the team/ux label and un-assigning UX folks. If priorities are changed in the future, please add the team/ux label |
Issue Overview
It is too easy to look at the planner list and think that a
closed
item is active. While planning, I almost never want to see finished work.Expected Behaviour
When I look at the list of items, the closed ones should be hidden behind a filter of some kind. Github does this with a tab that toggles the filters between Open and Closed.
Current Behaviour
Closed items are in the list
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: