spec(changes): delete the committed spec-changes.json and its merge=os-regen route; gitignore both projections; an unrouted pending path prints a remedy that works (#22485)

Ruling 6078203801 on #22449 (B'): the committed copies and their two
merge=os-regen routes are deleted. The guide's half landed with #22483;
this is the spec-changes.json half.

- packages/spec/spec-changes.json leaves git and is gitignored, with
  packages/spec/protocol-upgrade-guide.md. The publish lane still writes
  both into the package before npm pack, and files[] still ships them.
- .gitattributes drops the last projection route; regen-artifacts.mjs
  moves gen:spec-changes to NOT_DRIVER_MANAGED as untracked output, which
  the merge-driver self-test now holds against git. Comment counts in
  git-merge-regen.mjs follow (16 routed paths, 16 rows, 14 defaulted).
- build-spec-changes.ts writes no committed copy: its no-flag mode writes
  the gitignored package copy the lane and gen:spec-changes produce
  (projection-cli's committedPath becomes defaultPath).
- check-regen-pending: a pending path with no REGEN_ARTIFACTS row stays
  blocked, but now says why and prints the remedy that settles it, and
  --release PATH removes exactly that line (refusing a routed path or one
  that is not pending). Its fixture derives its pending row instead of
  naming spec-changes.json.
- check-generated's row text, os-regen-merge.sh's measured-path note and
  check-future-spec-major's exemption row for the deleted copy (forced:
  it matched nothing once the file was gone) follow.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VZqqwTj2wsihZEbfT6yyYN
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

Author: claude

.gitattributes

@@ -17,22 +17,14 @@
 # stay routed here as directories: the driver still owns a same-category
 # collision, which is the residue sharding cannot remove.
 #
-# One entry below is still a SINGLE file — spec-changes.json — and #8344 asked
-# what the driver-less queue does to it. MEASURED (2026-08-13, the real in-flight
-# case plus four synthetic pairs, each merged in a clone with no
-# merge.os-regen.driver, over it and the protocol upgrade guide, then a second
-# committed single file): the queue leaves neither stale-but-clean. Both were sorted
-# unions and an ADR-0087 registration is insertion-only, so the queue's text merge
-# either takes both sides — byte-identical to the regeneration, gates green — or
-# conflicts outright. It conflicts only when the two in-flight entries are ADJACENT
-# in registry sort order; one existing entry between them is already enough to
-# merge clean AND current.
-#
-# Sharding it would not buy back an ejection, which is why it is still a single
-# file: every conflicting case also conflicts in
-# packages/spec/src/migrations/registry.ts — generated, committed, unsharded,
-# NOT_DRIVER_MANAGED — and every registration touches it by construction. The table
-# and the reproduction are in packages/spec/src/migrations/entries/README.md.
+# packages/spec/spec-changes.json LEFT this list at #22485, because it left git: the
+# #22449 B′ ruling generates it at publish (`scripts/release-spec-changes.sh` writes
+# it into the package before the tarball is packed), the pull request generates it
+# in memory, and the file is gitignored. NOT_DRIVER_MANAGED records `gen:spec-changes`
+# as untracked output. A branch that still carries a regenerated copy meets a
+# modify/delete conflict when it merges main, and the deletion is the resolution:
+# `git rm packages/spec/spec-changes.json`, then commit — git runs no merge driver on
+# a modify/delete, so nothing is deferred and no marker is left.
 #
 # docs/protocol-upgrade-guide.md LEFT this list at #22483 because nothing generates
 # it any more. It is a hand-written pointer stub naming the guide's public address,
@@ -46,7 +38,9 @@
 # forked before #22483 still defers the guide on its first merge of main; the merged
 # tree has no row to discharge it against, so the next commit and the push are
 # refused instead of passed (measured on PR #22556 with the previous head as the
-# control, both merge directions).
+# control, both merge directions). Since #22485 that refusal names the path as
+# UNROUTED and prints the remedy that settles it — compare it with the merged-in
+# side, keep the right bytes, `node scripts/check-regen-pending.mjs --release PATH`.
 #
 # `merge=os-regen` hands those paths to `scripts/git-merge-regen.mjs`, which does
 # NOT text-merge them. See that file for why it also does not regenerate them
@@ -177,7 +171,6 @@
 # case where two branches' rows do not overlap and the text merge exits 0 describing
 # neither side.
 
-packages/spec/spec-changes.json                              merge=os-regen
 packages/spec/liveness/state-counts/**                       merge=os-regen
 packages/spec/authorable-surface/**                          merge=os-regen
 packages/spec/authorable-surface.base.json                   merge=os-regen

.gitignore

@@ -136,3 +136,9 @@ examples/app-crm/storage/
 # The release lane's scratch space: the previously published tarball it unpacks
 # and the artifact it packs to verify the ADR-0087 D4 per-release section.
 .release-spec-changes/
+# The two ADR-0087 D4 projections `@objectstack/spec` ships: generated INTO the
+# package by that lane (`scripts/release-spec-changes.sh --prepare` / `--generate`)
+# right before the tarball is packed, and by `gen:spec-changes` locally. Never
+# committed (#22449 B′, #22485); `files[]` ships whatever the lane wrote.
+packages/spec/spec-changes.json
+packages/spec/protocol-upgrade-guide.md

packages/spec/scripts/build-spec-changes.ts

@@ -13,13 +13,15 @@
  * WHERE it is generated (#22449 B′): at publish, by
  * `scripts/release-spec-changes.sh`, which writes it into the package before
  * `npm pack` and verifies the packed copy against a fresh generation. The
- * pull-request stage generates it IN MEMORY (`--check`) and compares no
- * committed copy, so a pull request that only adds a registry entry needs no
- * regeneration commit; `render-projection-diff.ts` renders the generated diff
- * against the base on the pull request instead. The command-line contract is
- * `lib/projection-cli.ts`.
+ * pull-request stage generates it IN MEMORY (`--check`), so a pull request that
+ * only adds a registry entry needs no regeneration commit;
+ * `render-projection-diff.ts` renders the generated diff against the base on the
+ * pull request instead. There is NO committed copy (#22485): the package path is
+ * gitignored, and the no-flag mode writes that untracked file — the one the
+ * lane's `--prepare` / `--generate` put there for `files[]` to ship. The
+ * command-line contract is `lib/projection-cli.ts`.
  *
- *   pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:spec-changes     # write the committed copy (until it is deleted)
+ *   pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:spec-changes     # write packages/spec/spec-changes.json (gitignored)
  *   pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:spec-changes   # CI: generate in memory, red when generation fails
  *   tsx scripts/build-spec-changes.ts --out <file>       # write the generated bytes anywhere
  *
@@ -61,17 +63,10 @@
  * exists to end. `scripts/check-release-spec-changes.mjs` derives the same
  * condition from the same artifacts and accepts the absence for the same reason.
  *
- * `spec-changes.json` itself stays a single file, deliberately (#5837), and #8344
- * re-measured that call rather than inheriting it. The original reason — "two PRs
- * append under different majors" — is not what actually holds: in-flight
- * registrations land in the SAME (current) major, so what separates them is their
- * distance in the registry's id sort order, not the major. What holds is the
- * conclusion. This file is a sorted union of an insertion-only registration, so a
- * driver-less server-side merge either takes both sides (byte-identical to the
- * regeneration) or conflicts; it is never stale-but-clean, it conflicts only on
- * ADJACENT ids, and in that case `src/migrations/registry.ts` — unsharded and
- * outside the merge driver — conflicts too, so splitting this file would not save
- * the PR. Measurement table: `../src/migrations/entries/README.md`.
+ * `spec-changes.json` is one file, not sharded (#5837, re-measured at #8344).
+ * That call was about MERGING a committed copy; since #22485 there is none, so
+ * nothing merges it and the question no longer arises. The measurement table it
+ * rested on stays in `../src/migrations/entries/README.md`.
  */
 
 import { readFileSync, existsSync } from 'node:fs';
@@ -95,7 +90,8 @@ import { exitWith, runProjectionCli } from './lib/projection-cli';
 import { API_SURFACE_DIR_NAME, readApiSurfaceFrom } from './lib/sharded-artifacts';
 
 const PKG_DIR = resolve(fileURLToPath(new URL('.', import.meta.url)), '..');
-const SNAPSHOT = resolve(PKG_DIR, 'spec-changes.json');
+/** The package's own copy — gitignored, written by the no-flag mode, shipped by `files[]`. */
+const PACKAGE_COPY = resolve(PKG_DIR, 'spec-changes.json');
 const SURFACE = resolve(PKG_DIR, API_SURFACE_DIR_NAME);
 const CHECK = process.argv.includes('--check');
 const prevSurfaceIdx = process.argv.indexOf('--previous-surface');
@@ -268,7 +264,7 @@ function build(): string {
   );
   const problem = surfaceScopeProblem(aggregate);
   if (problem) {
-    console.error(`Refusing to write ${SNAPSHOT}: ${problem}`);
+    console.error(`Refusing to write ${PACKAGE_COPY}: ${problem}`);
     process.exit(1);
   }
   const release = buildReleaseSection(aggregate);
@@ -329,7 +325,7 @@ function describeManifest(bytes: string): string {
 exitWith(
   runProjectionCli({
     name: 'spec-changes.json',
-    committedPath: SNAPSHOT,
+    defaultPath: PACKAGE_COPY,
     build,
     describe: describeManifest,
     argv: process.argv,

packages/spec/scripts/check-generated.ts

@@ -86,7 +86,14 @@ const GATED: ReadonlyArray<{
     gen: 'gen:migration-registry',
     artifact: 'src/migrations/registry.ts — its generated regions, from src/migrations/entries/',
   },
-  { check: 'check:spec-changes', gen: 'gen:spec-changes', artifact: 'spec-changes.json' },
+  // Its committed copy is gone too (#22485): the publish lane writes the shipped one
+  // into the package, `gen:spec-changes` writes the same gitignored file locally,
+  // and the gate generates in memory, so it never reports stale.
+  {
+    check: 'check:spec-changes',
+    gen: 'gen:spec-changes',
+    artifact: 'spec-changes.json (gitignored; written into the package at publish)',
+  },
   // Its committed copy is gone: `docs/protocol-upgrade-guide.md` is a hand-written
   // pointer stub, and `gen:upgrade-guide` writes the docs pages that are the
   // guide's address. The gate generates in memory, so it never reports stale.

packages/spec/scripts/lib/projection-cli.ts

@@ -8,16 +8,20 @@
  * Both are pure functions of the D2 conversion table and the D3 migration chain.
  * Since the #22449 B′ ruling they are generated where they ship — at publish, by
  * `scripts/release-spec-changes.sh` — and the pull-request stage generates them
- * IN MEMORY instead of comparing a committed copy:
+ * IN MEMORY. Neither has a committed copy any more (the guide's went at #22483,
+ * `spec-changes.json`'s at #22485):
  *
- *   (no flag)       write the bytes to the committed path. Kept only until the
- *                   committed copies are deleted; nothing gates on that copy.
- *                   A projection with no committed copy (the upgrade guide,
- *                   whose no-flag mode writes its docs pages instead) passes
- *                   no `committedPath`, and a bare run here is a usage error.
+ *   (no flag)       write the bytes to the projection's `defaultPath`. For
+ *                   `spec-changes.json` that is the package's own copy,
+ *                   `packages/spec/spec-changes.json`: gitignored, and the file
+ *                   `files[]` ships — the publish lane's `--prepare` /
+ *                   `--generate` run this mode right before `npm pack`. A
+ *                   projection with no such path (the upgrade guide, whose
+ *                   no-flag mode writes its docs pages instead) passes no
+ *                   `defaultPath`, and a bare run here is a usage error.
  *   --check         generate in memory and write NOTHING. Green means the
- *                   registries project; red means they do not. ⛔ No committed
- *                   copy is read, so a pull request that only adds a registry
+ *                   registries project; red means they do not. ⛔ Nothing on
+ *                   disk is read, so a pull request that only adds a registry
  *                   entry needs no regeneration commit.
  *   --out <path>    write the bytes to `<path>`. The publish lane uses it to put
  *                   the guide inside the package, and the pull-request diff
@@ -39,11 +43,12 @@ export interface ProjectionCliOptions {
   /** The projection's name in every message, e.g. `spec-changes.json`. */
   name: string;
   /**
-   * The committed copy the no-flag mode writes. Absent when the projection has
-   * none — the upgrade guide's no-flag mode is its own (the docs pages,
-   * `build-upgrade-guide.ts`) — and then a bare run is a usage error.
+   * Where the no-flag mode writes: an untracked, gitignored path, never a
+   * committed copy. Absent when the projection has none — the upgrade guide's
+   * no-flag mode is its own (the docs pages, `build-upgrade-guide.ts`) — and then
+   * a bare run is a usage error.
    */
-  committedPath?: string;
+  defaultPath?: string;
   /** The projection's bytes, from the registries. Throws when it cannot. */
   build: () => string;
   /** One clause describing generated bytes, for `--check`'s success line. */
@@ -79,8 +84,8 @@ export function runProjectionCli(opts: ProjectionCliOptions): ProjectionCliResul
   const usage = (line: string): ProjectionCliResult => ({ code: 2, stdout: [], stderr: [line], wrote: null });
 
   if (out === null) return usage(`--out needs a path: --out <file> (${opts.name}).`);
-  if (!check && out === undefined && opts.committedPath === undefined) {
-    return usage(`${opts.name} has no committed copy: pass --check (generate in memory) or --out <file>.`);
+  if (!check && out === undefined && opts.defaultPath === undefined) {
+    return usage(`${opts.name} has no default path: pass --check (generate in memory) or --out <file>.`);
   }
   if (check && out !== undefined) {
     return usage(
@@ -110,15 +115,15 @@ export function runProjectionCli(opts: ProjectionCliOptions): ProjectionCliResul
       code: 0,
       stdout: [
         `✓ ${opts.name} generates from the ADR-0087 registries, in memory${detail}.`,
-        '  No committed copy is compared: the publish lane generates the shipped one and verifies it from the tarball.',
+        '  No copy on disk is compared: the publish lane generates the shipped one and verifies it from the tarball.',
       ],
       stderr: [],
       wrote: null,
     };
   }
 
-  // `out ?? committedPath` is never undefined here: the usage check above refused that.
-  const target = resolve((out ?? opts.committedPath) as string);
+  // `out ?? defaultPath` is never undefined here: the usage check above refused that.
+  const target = resolve((out ?? opts.defaultPath) as string);
   mkdirSync(dirname(target), { recursive: true });
   writeFileSync(target, bytes);
   return { code: 0, stdout: [`Wrote ${target}`], stderr: [], wrote: target };

packages/spec/scripts/projection-cli.test.ts

@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
 // (`lib/projection-cli.ts`), which since the #22449 B′ ruling are generated at
 // publish and generated IN MEMORY on a pull request:
 //
-//   - `--check` reads and writes no committed copy, so a pull request that only
+//   - `--check` reads and writes no copy on disk, so a pull request that only
 //     adds a registry entry needs no regeneration commit;
 //   - a generation failure is red in every mode and writes nothing;
 //   - `--out` writes the generated bytes where it is told, and nowhere else.
@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ afterEach(() => {
 function options(over: Partial<ProjectionCliOptions> & { argv: string[] }): ProjectionCliOptions {
   return {
     name: 'fixture.json',
-    committedPath: path.join(tmp, 'committed', 'fixture.json'),
+    defaultPath: path.join(tmp, 'committed', 'fixture.json'),
     build: () => '{"generated":true}\n',
     ...over,
   };
@@ -119,14 +119,14 @@ describe('runProjectionCli — the two projections’ command-line contract', ()
     expect(fs.readFileSync(committed, 'utf8')).toBe('{"before":true}\n');
   });
 
-  it('with no flag it writes the committed copy', () => {
+  it('with no flag it writes the default path (the package copy, untracked since #22485)', () => {
     const result = runProjectionCli(options({ argv: [] }));
 
     expect(result.code).toBe(0);
     expect(fs.readFileSync(path.join(tmp, 'committed', 'fixture.json'), 'utf8')).toBe('{"generated":true}\n');
   });
 
-  it('with no flag and no committed copy it refuses as a usage error, builds nothing and writes nothing', () => {
+  it('with no flag and no default path it refuses as a usage error, builds nothing and writes nothing', () => {
     let builds = 0;
     const result = runProjectionCli({
       name: 'fixture.json',
@@ -138,7 +138,7 @@ describe('runProjectionCli — the two projections’ command-line contract', ()
     });
 
     expect(result.code).toBe(2);
-    expect(result.stderr.join('\n')).toContain('fixture.json has no committed copy');
+    expect(result.stderr.join('\n')).toContain('fixture.json has no default path');
     expect(result.wrote).toBeNull();
     expect(builds).toBe(0);
     expect(fs.readdirSync(tmp)).toEqual([]);