Skip to content

Conversation

AlexanderPortland
Copy link
Contributor

Context

When working on #4211 & #4213, I was initially very confused by all the machinery in call_cargo.rs and call_single_file.rs that we used to pass arguments to the different layers of the compiler. The main source of my confusion was that there were many arguments all destined for different places (e.g. cargo, rustc, or kani-compiler) that all had to be encoded in differing ways (e.g. through the --llvm-args flag or the CARGO_ENCODED_RUSTFLAGS environment variable) but were mixed together sharing the same String type and similar-sounding variable names.

Although misconfiguration would often be caught at runtime with a section of the compiler complaining about unexpected arguments, this confusion silently bit me a few times where argument names were shared.

Fix

This PR represents an attempt to encode the way arguments target different portions of the compiler into the type system using specific wrapper types for each kind of argument we use. You can convert transparently into these wrapper types, but then can only convert between them or pass them to a cargo command using the proper encoding methods.

Although not perfect (you could still convert into the wrong kind of argument wrapper initially), this does seem to add some slight guardrails on the way we call cargo, especially against smaller changes to the existing patterns like the ones I was making in my PRs. It also may make the code easier to parse.

By submitting this pull request, I confirm that my contribution is made under the terms of the Apache 2.0 and MIT licenses.

@github-actions github-actions bot added Z-EndToEndBenchCI Tag a PR to run benchmark CI Z-CompilerBenchCI Tag a PR to run benchmark CI labels Jul 11, 2025
@AlexanderPortland AlexanderPortland changed the title [DRAFT] Strongly type differing compiler args for clarity Strongly type differing compiler args for clarity Jul 14, 2025
@AlexanderPortland AlexanderPortland marked this pull request as ready for review July 14, 2025 19:24
@AlexanderPortland AlexanderPortland requested a review from a team as a code owner July 14, 2025 19:24
@carolynzech carolynzech self-requested a review July 14, 2025 20:11
@carolynzech carolynzech self-assigned this Jul 14, 2025
Copy link
Contributor

@carolynzech carolynzech left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

First round of comments. Overall I am happy with this, think it's a nice improvement that makes it clearer how things work.

@AlexanderPortland
Copy link
Contributor Author

I re-examined the code with feedback in mind (specifically the use of pass_kani_args and to_rustc_args feeling redundant) and came up with some changes.

  • the redundancy was originally done out of fear that calling pass_rustc_args with PassTo::AllCrates multiple times would overwrite all but the last call (since we use an environment variable to encode the flags in that case). this turned out to be true, so I added an assertion to detect this and point to a fix.
  • because of this, I thought it made sense to remove the pass_kani_args method and instead have users use the pub to_rustc_args to pass their KaniArgs into the same pass_rustc_args calls as their RustcArgs. This way, you can call pass_rustc_args(..., PassTo::AllCrates) only once on each command with all the arguments you'd like to encode into the environment variable. it's also fairly easy to just recreate the behavior of the old pass_kani_args in the few cases that it's needed.

(doesn't really change anything but i think it's fun)
Copy link
Contributor

@carolynzech carolynzech left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

🎉 Thanks! Excited about this

@carolynzech carolynzech added this pull request to the merge queue Jul 22, 2025
@github-merge-queue github-merge-queue bot removed this pull request from the merge queue due to failed status checks Jul 22, 2025
@carolynzech
Copy link
Contributor

#4213 merged first, so now we get this error in the queue:

error[E0308]: mismatched types
   --> kani-driver/src/call_single_file.rs:167:24
    |
167 |             flags.push(format!("--harness {harness}"));
    |                        ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ expected `KaniArg`, found `String`
    |
    = note: this error originates in the macro `format` (in Nightly builds, run with -Z macro-backtrace for more info)
help: call `Into::into` on this expression to convert `std::string::String` into `KaniArg`
    |
167 |             flags.push(format!("--harness {harness}").into());
    |                                                      +++++++

@AlexanderPortland can you merge main into this branch and update the new code so that it compiles?

@AlexanderPortland AlexanderPortland added this pull request to the merge queue Jul 22, 2025
Merged via the queue into model-checking:main with commit 5af25b5 Jul 22, 2025
17 of 18 checks passed
@AlexanderPortland AlexanderPortland deleted the typed-args branch July 22, 2025 03:57
github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 7, 2025
from the autogenerated : 

## What's Changed
* Ensure that contract closures are FnOnce by @vonaka in
#4151
* Adjust sized hierarchy for Kani's memory predicates by @tautschnig in
#4193
* Update to Rust edition 2024 by @tautschnig in
#4197
* `ptr_offset_from`: Replace arithmetic over pointers by offset
arithmetic by @tautschnig in
#4180
* Automatic cargo update to 2025-07-07 by @github-actions[bot] in
#4208
* Bump tests/perf/s2n-quic from `b8f8cca` to `8715fdf` by
@dependabot[bot] in #4209
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-04 by @tautschnig in
#4199
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-10 by @thanhnguyen-aws in
#4215
* Update CBMC dependency to 6.7.1 by @tautschnig in
#4178
* Split compiler flags to avoid dependency recompilation by
@AlexanderPortland in #4211
* Fix the bug that assign clause cannot be inferred for the inner loop
of nested loops by @thanhnguyen-aws in
#4179
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-11 by @thanhnguyen-aws in
#4219
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-07-12 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4222
* Fix bug: `goto-cc` crash when there are two quantifers in one proof by
@thanhnguyen-aws in #4221
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-07-13 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4223
* Automatic cargo update to 2025-07-14 by @github-actions[bot] in
#4224
* Cleanup links to issues that have been addressed by @tautschnig in
#4200
* Selectively enable and fix (slow) Tokio tests by @tautschnig in
#4203
* Bump tests/perf/s2n-quic from `32ba87d` to `1cbd879` by
@dependabot[bot] in #4227
* Implement support for Cargo.toml's default-members by @tautschnig in
#4201
* Do not invoke memset with count of zero by @tautschnig in
#4205
* Support bitwuzla, cvc5, z3 as solver attribute values by @tautschnig
in #4218
* Use CBMC's shuffle_vector expression by @tautschnig in
#4204
* Move tests from slow/kani back to regular suite by @tautschnig in
#4202
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-07-14 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4225
* Enable GitHub Linux/Arm runners in CI by @tautschnig in
#3841
* Automatic cargo update to 2025-07-21 by @github-actions[bot] in
#4231
* Skip codegen for unneeded harnesses by @AlexanderPortland in
#4213
* Strongly type differing compiler args for clarity by
@AlexanderPortland in #4220
* Remove StableMIR ICE workaround by @carolynzech in
#4235
* Fix bug: Kani unwinds loops with contract in generic function (with -Z
loop-contracts) by @thanhnguyen-aws in
#4232
* Automatic cargo update to 2025-07-28 by @github-actions[bot] in
#4238
* Bump tests/perf/s2n-quic from `1cbd879` to `4938450` by
@dependabot[bot] in #4242
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-21 by @tautschnig in
#4241
* Remove `pretty_ty` and use rustc_public's formatter instead by
@tautschnig in #4243
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-24 by @tautschnig in
#4244
* Documentation cleanup of UB detected by Kani by @tautschnig in
#4245
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-07-29 by @tautschnig in
#4247
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-07-30 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4253
* Add unstable option prove-safety-only by @tautschnig in
#4239
* Set bits_per_byte in byte_extract expressions by @tautschnig in
#4255
* `KaniAttributes` Path Resolution Refactor by @carolynzech in
#4249
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-07-31 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4256
* Support contracts & stubs in trait implementations (partial fix) by
@carolynzech in #4250
* [Breaking Changes] Remove unstable list feature and default memory
checks by @carolynzech in
#4258
* Upgrade Rust toolchain to 2025-08-01 by @tautschnig in
#4261
* Autoharness: add support for references by @tautschnig in
#4234
* Turn off debug assertions under `--prove-safety-only` by @tautschnig
in #4262
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-08-02 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4264
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-08-03 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4265
* Automatic cargo update to 2025-08-04 by @github-actions[bot] in
#4267
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-08-04 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4266
* Introduce thread pool for writing goto binaries in parallel by
@AlexanderPortland in #4236
* Major-version update cargo dependencies by @tautschnig in
#4240
* Bump tests/perf/s2n-quic from `4938450` to `8f510f0` by
@dependabot[bot] in #4270
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-08-05 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4271
* Automatic toolchain upgrade to nightly-2025-08-06 by
@github-actions[bot] in #4272
* Avoid updating irrelevant symbols when handling quantifiers by
@AlexanderPortland in #4268
* Lazily evaluate debug info by @AlexanderPortland in
#4269
* Clone a template `BodyTransformer` to avoid re-initialization by
@AlexanderPortland in #4259
* Ensuring that MIR constants are marked as static consts by @vonaka in
#4233
* Fix release job dependencies by @tautschnig in
#4273

## New Contributors
* @vonaka made their first contribution in
#4151

**Full Changelog**:
kani-0.64.0...kani-0.65.0

---------

Co-authored-by: Zyad Hassan <88045115+zhassan-aws@users.noreply.github.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Z-CompilerBenchCI Tag a PR to run benchmark CI Z-EndToEndBenchCI Tag a PR to run benchmark CI
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants