Bugfix: SuspenseList incorrectly forces a fallback (#26453)

Fixes a bug in SuspenseList that @kassens found when deploying React to
Meta. In some scenarios, SuspenseList would force the fallback of a
deeply nested Suspense boundary into fallback mode, which should never
happen under any circumstances — SuspenseList should only affect the
nearest descendent Suspense boundaries, without going deeper.

The cause was that the internal ForceSuspenseFallback context flag was
not being properly reset when it reached the nearest Suspense boundary.
It should only be propagated shallowly.

We didn't discover this earlier because the scenario where it happens is
not that common. To trigger the bug, you need to insert a new Suspense
boundary into an already-mounted row of the list. But often when a new
Suspense boundary is rendered, it suspends and shows a fallback, anyway,
because its content hasn't loaded yet.

Another reason we didn't discover this earlier is because there was
another bug that was accidentally masking it, which was fixed by #25922.
When that fix landed, it revealed this bug.

The SuspenseList implementation is complicated but I'm not too concerned
with the current messiness. It's an experimental API, and we intend to
release it soon, but there are some known flaws and missing features
that we need to address first regardless. We'll likely end up rewriting
most of it.

Co-authored-by: Jan Kassens <jkassens@meta.com>

Author: acdlite

packages/react-reconciler/src/ReactFiberBeginWork.js

@@ -2167,6 +2167,8 @@ function shouldRemainOnFallback(
   // If we're already showing a fallback, there are cases where we need to
   // remain on that fallback regardless of whether the content has resolved.
   // For example, SuspenseList coordinates when nested content appears.
+  // TODO: For compatibility with offscreen prerendering, this should also check
+  // whether the current fiber (if it exists) was visible in the previous tree.
   if (current !== null) {
     const suspenseState: SuspenseState = current.memoizedState;
     if (suspenseState === null) {

packages/react-reconciler/src/ReactFiberSuspenseContext.js

@@ -45,6 +45,14 @@ export function pushPrimaryTreeSuspenseHandler(handler: Fiber): void {
   const current = handler.alternate;
   const props: SuspenseProps = handler.pendingProps;
 
+  // Shallow Suspense context fields, like ForceSuspenseFallback, should only be
+  // propagated a single level. For example, when ForceSuspenseFallback is set,
+  // it should only force the nearest Suspense boundary into fallback mode.
+  pushSuspenseListContext(
+    handler,
+    setDefaultShallowSuspenseListContext(suspenseStackCursor.current),
+  );
+
   // Experimental feature: Some Suspense boundaries are marked as having an
   // undesirable fallback state. These have special behavior where we only
   // activate the fallback if there's no other boundary on the stack that we can
@@ -100,6 +108,11 @@ export function pushFallbackTreeSuspenseHandler(fiber: Fiber): void {
 
 export function pushOffscreenSuspenseHandler(fiber: Fiber): void {
   if (fiber.tag === OffscreenComponent) {
+    // A SuspenseList context is only pushed here to avoid a push/pop mismatch.
+    // Reuse the current value on the stack.
+    // TODO: We can avoid needing to push here by by forking popSuspenseHandler
+    // into separate functions for Suspense and Offscreen.
+    pushSuspenseListContext(fiber, suspenseStackCursor.current);
     push(suspenseHandlerStackCursor, fiber, fiber);
     if (shellBoundary !== null) {
       // A parent boundary is showing a fallback, so we've already rendered
@@ -122,6 +135,7 @@ export function pushOffscreenSuspenseHandler(fiber: Fiber): void {
 }
 
 export function reuseSuspenseHandlerOnStack(fiber: Fiber) {
+  pushSuspenseListContext(fiber, suspenseStackCursor.current);
   push(suspenseHandlerStackCursor, getSuspenseHandler(), fiber);
 }
 
@@ -135,6 +149,7 @@ export function popSuspenseHandler(fiber: Fiber): void {
     // Popping back into the shell.
     shellBoundary = null;
   }
+  popSuspenseListContext(fiber);
 }
 
 // SuspenseList context

packages/react-reconciler/src/__tests__/ReactSuspenseList-test.js

@@ -3003,4 +3003,108 @@ describe('ReactSuspenseList', () => {
       </>,
     );
   });
+
+  // @gate enableSuspenseList
+  it(
+    'regression test: SuspenseList should never force boundaries deeper than ' +
+      'a single level into fallback mode',
+    async () => {
+      const A = createAsyncText('A');
+
+      function UnreachableFallback() {
+        throw new Error('Should never be thrown!');
+      }
+
+      function Repro({update}) {
+        return (
+          <SuspenseList revealOrder="forwards">
+            {update && (
+              <Suspense fallback={<Text text="Loading A..." />}>
+                <A />
+              </Suspense>
+            )}
+            <Suspense fallback={<Text text="Loading B..." />}>
+              {update ? (
+                <Suspense fallback={<UnreachableFallback />}>
+                  <Text text="B2" />
+                </Suspense>
+              ) : (
+                <Text text="B1" />
+              )}
+            </Suspense>
+            <Suspense fallback={<Text text="Loading C..." />}>
+              <Text text="C" />
+            </Suspense>
+            {update && (
+              <Suspense fallback={<Text text="Loading D..." />}>
+                <Text text="D" />
+              </Suspense>
+            )}
+          </SuspenseList>
+        );
+      }
+
+      // Initial mount. Only two rows are mounted, B and C.
+      const root = ReactNoop.createRoot();
+      await act(() => root.render(<Repro update={false} />));
+      assertLog(['B1', 'C']);
+      expect(root).toMatchRenderedOutput(
+        <>
+          <span>B1</span>
+          <span>C</span>
+        </>,
+      );
+
+      // During the update, a few things happen simultaneously:
+      // - A new row, A, is inserted into the head. This row suspends.
+      // - The context in row B is replaced. The new content contains a nested
+      //   Suspense boundary.
+      // - A new row, D, is inserted into the tail.
+      await act(() => root.render(<Repro update={true} />));
+      assertLog([
+        // During the first pass, the new row, A, suspends. This means any new
+        // rows in the tail should be forced into fallback mode.
+        'Suspend! [A]',
+        'Loading A...',
+        'B2',
+        'C',
+
+        // A second pass is used to render the fallbacks in the tail.
+        //
+        // Rows B and C were already mounted, so they should not be forced into
+        // fallback mode.
+        //
+        // In the regression that this test was written for, the inner
+        // Suspense boundary around B2 was incorrectly activated. Only the
+        // nearest fallbacks per row should be activated, and only if they
+        // haven't already mounted.
+        'Loading A...',
+        'B2',
+        'C',
+
+        // D is part of the tail, so it should show a fallback.
+        'Loading D...',
+      ]);
+      expect(root).toMatchRenderedOutput(
+        <>
+          <span>Loading A...</span>
+          <span>B2</span>
+          <span>C</span>
+          <span>Loading D...</span>
+        </>,
+      );
+
+      // Now finish loading A.
+      await act(() => A.resolve());
+      assertLog(['A', 'D']);
+      expect(root).toMatchRenderedOutput(
+        <>
+          <span>A</span>
+          <span>B2</span>
+          <span>C</span>
+          <span>D</span>
+        </>,
+      );
+    },
+  );
 });