`focus_below` binding works inconsistently

[strogonoff]

Describe the bug

Key assigned to focus_below works correctly on commit details screen, but on status screen it does not have desired effect (which would presumably be “focus the staging pane, if current focus is in unstaged changes pane”).

Same happens with focus_above, however focus_left or focus_right work correctly.

To Reproduce

My key configuration is this (but I found it works with any bindings):

focus_right: Some(( code: Char('l'), modifiers: ( bits: 2,),)),
focus_left: Some(( code: Char('h'), modifiers: ( bits: 2,),)),
focus_above: Some(( code: Char('k'), modifiers: ( bits: 2,),)),
focus_below: Some(( code: Char('j'), modifiers: ( bits: 2,),)),

1. Open gitui (defaults to status screen, focusing unstaged change list)
2. Hit ctrl+j
3. Nothing happens

Expected behavior

3. Takes focus to staging area

Screenshots
—

Context (please complete the following information):

• Terminal: Alacritty
• OS/Distro + Version: macOS 13.2
• GitUI Version 0.22.1
• Rust version: rustc 1.67.0 fc594f156

Additional context
—

[extrawurst]

try

    move_left: Some(( code: Char('h'), modifiers: ( bits: 0,),)),
    move_right: Some(( code: Char('l'), modifiers: ( bits: 0,),)),
    move_up: Some(( code: Char('k'), modifiers: ( bits: 0,),)),
    move_down: Some(( code: Char('j'), modifiers: ( bits: 0,),)),

see here: https://github.com/extrawurst/gitui/blob/master/KEY_CONFIG.md

anyway I think this brings up a good point, why do we have both sets move_... and focus_... so I am using this ticket to consolidate them into one set. will most likely be bound to the same keys anyway

[strogonoff]

You are suggesting me to unset the modifier bit, which is the entire point of my modification to the snippet linked from README.

anyway I think this brings up a good point, why do we have both sets move_... and focus_... so I am using this ticket to consolidate them into one set. will most likely be bound to the same keys anyway

The difference is obvious to me: I don’t want to scroll through 24 changed filed in order to jump to lower pane. I assume move_* moves one item and focus_* focuses the pane—which works except for top/down pane movements.

[extrawurst]

The difference is obvious to me: I don’t want to scroll through 24 changed filed in order to jump to lower pane

this is not how it worked before anyway. there is a specific toggle for toggling between focusing workarea and staging that is called toggle_workarea (defaults to w).

for using the control bit 2: it works in my iterm2 on Mac. so its probably your terminal eating that code before it arrives in gitui

[strogonoff]

this is not how it worked before anyway. there is a specific toggle for toggling between focusing workarea and staging that is called toggle_workarea (defaults to w).

Doh!! Thanks for the pointer!

for using the control bit 2: it works in my iterm2 on Mac. so its probably your terminal eating that code before it arrives in gitui

But the control bit works for me too! Just not for focus up/down (only for left/right). That’s the inconsistency I wanted to report originally. Of course it increasingly looks like I actually don’t get how it’s supposed to work ;)