EIP Editing Office Hour Meeting 46

[poojaranjan]

Date & Time

Tuesday, Oct 29th 15th, 2024 at 14:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA on EthCatHerders Discord #eip-editors
Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxqnDHxOyuwMpyt5s8F8gdmO

Agenda

• Visit Ethereum Improvement Proposals

To Final

• Update ERC-7007: Move to Final ethereum/ERCs#662

To Last Call

TBA

To Review

EIPs
TBA

ERCs

• Update ERC-7417: Move to Review ethereum/ERCs#658
• Update ERC-7726: Move to Review ethereum/ERCs#688
• Update ERC-7751: Move to Review ethereum/ERCs#690

[From Stagnant]

TBA

Misc.

TBA

To Draft

EIPs
TBA

ERCs

• Add ERC: ERC-20 Transfer Reference Extension ethereum/ERCs#399 (review)
• Add ERC: Governance for Human Robot Societies ethereum/ERCs#660
• Add ERC: Soulbound Degradable Governance ethereum/ERCs#674
• Add ERC: JSON-RPC API for ERC-4337 ethereum/ERCs#628
• Add ERC: Signature Aggregation for ERC-4337 ethereum/ERCs#626
• Add ERC: Decentralized Identity Verification (DID) ethereum/ERCs#517
• Add ERC: Sovereign Bridged Token ethereum/ERCs#89
• Add ERC: Smart Contract Identifiers and Metadata Extension ethereum/ERCs#265
• Add ERC: Interoperable Delegated Accounts ethereum/ERCs#663
• Add ERC: Grant Registry ethereum/ERCs#680
• Add ERC: Transparent Financial Statements ethereum/ERCs#659
• Add ERC: Conditional send transaction RPC ethereum/ERCs#682

Open Q&A

• Could we include PRs from here?

• Update EIP-7702: Prohibit nonce-changing opcodes ethereum/EIPs#8538
• Bump nokogiri from 1.14.3 to 1.16.5 ethereum/EIPs#8554
• Update EIP-7609: From discussion ethereum/EIPs#8589
• Update EIP-2539: fix typos ethereum/EIPs#8611
• Update EIP-7639: Fix Paris/TheMerge 1th block number ethereum/EIPs#8616
• Update EIP-5792: make atomicBatch chain-specific per-batch, not per-call (both in protocol messages and in normative prose) ethereum/EIPs#8626
• https://github.com/ziljah ethereum/EIPs#8643
• Update EIP-7703: fix typos ethereum/EIPs#8676
• Update README: Add instructions for a more thorough linter ethereum/EIPs#8699
• Update EIP-5792: Spelling ethereum/EIPs#8739
• Update EIP-196: Fix coordinate description ethereum/EIPs#8741
• Add EIP: EVM Modular Arithmetic Extensions ethereum/EIPs#8743
• Add peerPermit EIP draft ethereum/EIPs#8758
• Bump rexml from 3.2.5 to 3.3.3 ethereum/EIPs#8778
• Update EIP-7732: fix typos ethereum/EIPs#8794
• Update EIP-5792: Propose changes to EIP-5792 ethereum/EIPs#8826
• CI: Generate ordered lists of pull requests needing review ethereum/EIPs#8831
• ERC-6809 Custom SafeFallback Extension ethereum/EIPs#8898
• Add EIP: ERC721AS - Auto Staking ethereum/EIPs#8902
• Add EIP: No-Ether transactions with free-for-all tips ethereum/EIPs#8888
• Update EIP-2537: double each discount table value in the MSM gas cost model ethereum/EIPs#8910
• Add EIP: Backward-Compatible Post-Quantum Migration ethereum/EIPs#8454
• Create a policy for patents ethereum/EIPs#8919
• Update EIP-2537: Remove redundant MUL precompiles ethereum/EIPs#8945
• Update EIP-7667: clarify 512 GAS sentence ethereum/EIPs#8952
• EIP-3670 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.22.25) ethereum/EIPs#8953
• EIP-6690 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.22.35) ethereum/EIPs#8954
• EIP-6913 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.22.45) ethereum/EIPs#8955
• EIP-7377 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.22.55) ethereum/EIPs#8956
• EIP-7645 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.23.5) ethereum/EIPs#8957
• EIP-7650 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.23.15) ethereum/EIPs#8958
• EIP-7666 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.23.35) ethereum/EIPs#8960
• EIP-7668 stagnant (2024-Oct-13th@00.23.45) ethereum/EIPs#8961
• Update EIP-7702: Remove delegation behavior of EXTCODE* ethereum/EIPs#8969
• Add EIP: GAS2ETH opcode ethereum/EIPs#8980
• Add EIP: TXINDEX precompile ethereum/EIPs#8981
• Update EIP-1186: fix typo ethereum/EIPs#8986
• Update EIP-712: Update eip-712.md ethereum/EIPs#8987
• Update EIP-7685: exclude empty requests data in commitment ethereum/EIPs#8989
• Config: Fixes ethereum/eipw#113 ethereum/EIPs#8991
• Add EIP: Double speed for hash_tree_root ethereum/EIPs#8995
• Add EIP: BLOB Data and Rollup Operator Rewards ethereum/EIPs#8993

Next meeting date/time?

Other details

• Announcement Blogpost

(Drop the Pull Request number to be added to the agenda.)

[ShaohongZ]

@poojaranjan Hi Pooja, could you add ethereum/ERC#660 please? Many thanks.

[0xneves]

Hey @poojaranjan , could you please add ERC#674 for this meeting? 🙈😅 Sorry for the late!

[poojaranjan]

The Editor is unable to attend today's meeting. I have updated the agenda to reschedule the meeting for two weeks starting today. Feel free to add your comments for review, which will be done asynchronously this week

[drortirosh]

While trying to "finalize" ERC-4337, we came into the conclusion that while some part of it is stable (the on-chain contract interfaces), some other parts (rpc calls and off-chain aggregation handling by bundlers) are not.
For this purpose, we wanted to split ERC-4337 into different ERCs.
We created PRs for the new fragments:

• ERC-7769 - JSON RPC for ERC-4337 Add ERC: JSON-RPC API for ERC-4337 ethereum/ERCs#628
• ERC-7766 - Aggregation for ERC-4337 Add ERC: Signature Aggregation for ERC-4337 ethereum/ERCs#626

Once these PRs are added, we can extract their content from ERC-4337 itself.

[PowerStream3604]

Hi @poojaranjan , could you please add ethereum/ERCs#663 for this meeting? Thank you!

[0xneves]

Hey @poojaranjan , please add ethereum/ERCs#680 for the next meeting. Thank you.

[radeksvarz]

Hey @poojaranjan , can you please add merging of ERC-7699 -ethereum/ERCs#399 (review)
(required changes were reflected)

[Nachoxt17]

Hello @poojaranjan , Could the ERC-7776 please be added to the next office hours (All the reviews have been corrected +2 weeks ago), re-reviewed if necessary and merged if possible? I would highly appreciate it🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼.

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #366