Skip to content

Implement tagged atomics #1

Open
@lorentey

Description

@lorentey

This package needs to provide convenient support for tagged atomics, where each atomic value carries some additional information (a version counter, a set of bit flags, etc.). Concurrent data structures tend to heavily rely on the ability to encode extra bits into atomic values to e.g. fight ABA issues or to mark obsolete-but-not-yet-unlinked nodes, etc.

This is especially important for atomic pointers, whose use cases are very limited without a way to augment their values with a version number and/or some other flags.

Ideally this would fit into the existing generic infrastructure, perhaps with a syntax like the tagged optional pointer below:

struct Foo { ... }
let taggedPointer = ManagedAtomic<Tagged<UnsafeMutablePointer<Foo>?, Int>>(nil, 0)

Most but not all tagged atomic values correspond to untagged values that implement single-word atomics.

The crucial exceptions are atomic strong references -- these are a particularly important special case, so they need to be tackled in the same effort, although they may end up requiring custom one-off APIs. (The number of bits available for custom tags in atomic strong references is limited by the fact that regular strong references are already double-wide constructs. This may prove too limiting to handle in a single unified Tagged construct. But a design that manages to do it would deserve bonus points!)

One straightforward option is for Tagged<Left, Right> is to require both Left and Right to be single-word AtomicValue types. Sadly this would require a separate type for tagged references.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    enhancementNew feature or request

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions