Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Witch Doctor #685

Open
Areshar opened this issue Sep 2, 2019 · 12 comments
Open

Witch Doctor #685

Areshar opened this issue Sep 2, 2019 · 12 comments
Labels
❓ suggestion - feature ⭐ Suggestion for adding a new feature to the mod ❓ suggestion - lore 📚 Problem or change that is specific to the lore or history found in-game ❓ suggestion ❓ Suggestion for improvement in the mod ❌ info needed 📄 More information needed here.

Comments

@Areshar
Copy link

Areshar commented Sep 2, 2019

DO NOT REMOVE PRE-EXISTING LINES

Describe your suggestion in full detail below:
Hi there,
I would like to ask if its possible to combine Loa Priest with Necromancer, because it would (atleast at Roleplaying) create something that looks like iconic jungle troll class, which is Witch Doctor. I dont need whole new class... but it seems impossible to have both loa priest and necromancer on one character.

@Areshar Areshar added the ❓ suggestion ❓ Suggestion for improvement in the mod label Sep 2, 2019
@zumbak04 zumbak04 added ❌ info needed 📄 More information needed here. ❓ suggestion - lore 📚 Problem or change that is specific to the lore or history found in-game ❓ suggestion - feature ⭐ Suggestion for adding a new feature to the mod labels Sep 3, 2019
@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 3, 2019

Loa Priest is based on Witch Doctors (mostly from Wacraft 3). The trolls call every mage a witch doctor even if it's clear Nercomancer like Zanzil the Outcast.

@Areshar
Copy link
Author

Areshar commented Sep 3, 2019

Ok. I cannot say, i agree that trolls see every mage as witch doctor, but i understand, what you mean. My problem with it, is that witch doctors (even good ones) should be able to communicate (possibly raise undead), but in-game i cannot be both Loa Priest and Necromancer at the same time. This combination would provide most sense as witch doctor. Heal and Hex of Loa Priest with Raise undead of Necromancer.

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 3, 2019

The most of witch doctors aren't necromancers and can't raise the dead. I know only Zum'rah and Zanzil.
https://wow.gamepedia.com/Zanzil_the_Outcast
https://wow.gamepedia.com/Witch_Doctor_Zum%27rah
And both of them can be clasified as necromancers.

@Areshar
Copy link
Author

Areshar commented Sep 3, 2019

I agree that witch doctors are not necromancers, but they use voodoo. And voodoo is usually shadow/dark magic. One of powers you gain or you could possibly learn to cast is raise the dead. So as you said, many witch doctors dont raise the dead, but i would say, thats by their choice and not by the lack of talent or different magic school.

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 3, 2019

Yep, that's their choice to pick Necromancer class. Again, I wouldn't classify them as anything besides necromancer. They raise the dead... and that's all. Otherwise, we will get Warlock + Loa Priest (https://wow.gamepedia.com/Witchdoctor_Yoksa), Shadow Priest + Loa Priest (https://wow.gamepedia.com/Jin%27do_the_Hexxer), Mage + Loa Priest (https://wow.gamepedia.com/Jin%27do_the_Hexxer), Druid + Loa Priest and Shaman + Loa Priest (https://wow.gamepedia.com/Nezzliok_the_Dire, https://wow.gamepedia.com/Witch_Doctor_Unbugu) and all of them will be named Witch Doctors.

@Areshar
Copy link
Author

Areshar commented Sep 3, 2019

I agree. That´s why i would like to have choice ingame to be both loa-priest and necromancer. Because by occasionally raising few dead people, you will not lose your healing and hex powers :-D

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 3, 2019

you will not lose your healing and hex powers :-D

Such witch doctors don't have hex powers and healing. That's the main problem. Check servants of Bwonsamdi.

@Areshar
Copy link
Author

Areshar commented Sep 4, 2019

There is atleast one that have power of raise the dead and healing https://wow.gamepedia.com/Witch_Doctor_Zum%27rah, even though he doesn´t have hexes is his spellbook... he should be able to cast them in lore.
There is another that has healing power, hexes and summon shade, which could be counted as "undead or shadow creature" https://wow.gamepedia.com/Jin%27do_the_Hexxer.
For me Witch Doctor is alchemist (potions/elixirs/poisons) and spellcaster that uses usually nature and shadow magic and if someone is telling me that shadow magic is not used for necromancy rituals(not always ofc), than thats mistake on his/her part.

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 4, 2019

There is atleast one that have power of raise the dead and healing https://wow.gamepedia.com/Witch_Doctor_Zum%27rah, even though he doesn´t have hexes is his spellbook... he should be able to cast them in lore.
There is another that has healing power, hexes and summon shade, which could be counted as "undead or shadow creature" https://wow.gamepedia.com/Jin%27do_the_Hexxer.

Witch Doctors from early WoW expansions have EVERY time of magic in speelbook. Shame on Blizzard. So, if we add Loa Priest + Necromancer, there should be Loa Priest + Mage, Loa Priest + Prist, Loa Priest + Shadow Priest, Loa Priest + Warlock. I left links in the message above. Sadly, I would like to remove Loa Priest class then and just add Witch Doctor subclass trait (like Moon Priest) that gives hex ability to every class.

For me Witch Doctor is alchemist (potions/elixirs/poisons) and spellcaster that uses usually nature and shadow magic and if someone is telling me that shadow magic is not used for necromancy rituals(not always ofc), than thats mistake on his/her part.

Not, it's not.
https://wow.gamepedia.com/Undead
Blizzard said it in the Chronicles.

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 4, 2019

Can suggest you one thing: subclass of Necromancer that gives you hex ability. But have no idea how to name it (and on what base it). It's not witch doctor since the most of them have nothing to do with nercomancy.

@Areshar
Copy link
Author

Areshar commented Sep 4, 2019

Not, it's not.
https://wow.gamepedia.com/Undead
Blizzard said it in the Chronicles.

I dont know that. Thank you for clarification.
Though i would still think its related, if Light and Void are most fundamental forces in WoW Universe, i would assume that, when Light could resurrect person with Holy magic, Void should do opposite of it.
Even if witch doctors dont use necromantic powers... how is it possible that in https://wow.gamepedia.com/Voodoo, there is text, which directly states raising the dead?

@zumbak04
Copy link
Member

zumbak04 commented Sep 4, 2019

Even if witch doctors dont use necromantic powers... how is it possible that in https://wow.gamepedia.com/Voodoo, there is text, which directly states raising the dead?

The trolls call everything voodoo and every mage a witch doctor... even if it's necromancer. Shame on them.

Though i would still think its related, if Light and Void are most fundamental forces in WoW Universe, i would assume that, when Light could resurrect person with Holy magic, Void should do opposite of it.

If you mean Calia, it's not clear yet. Blizzard said that the Light "touched" her.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
❓ suggestion - feature ⭐ Suggestion for adding a new feature to the mod ❓ suggestion - lore 📚 Problem or change that is specific to the lore or history found in-game ❓ suggestion ❓ Suggestion for improvement in the mod ❌ info needed 📄 More information needed here.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants