Skip to content

booleanPointInPolygon function not working as expected #2864

Open
@gabsone

Description

@gabsone

Description:
The turf.booleanPointInPolygon function consistently returns incorrect results when checking if a specific point is within a polygon. Even though the provided point clearly lies within the boundaries defined by the polygon coordinates, the function incorrectly returns false.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Create a point:
let ship = turf.point([48.085345, -24.812173333333334]);
  1. Define the polygon using provided coordinates (polygon definition attached below).
let polygon=turf.polygon([[[103.80597708106134,1.1706523988804578],[103.79735625227198,1.1849031566750978],[103.73431605555935,1.1467677290341145],[103.66230286904077,1.1933799006715895],[103.65957951738504,1.1945193520412456],[103.41183202819165,1.2494210784883315],[102.86073688589278,1.6508976301178329],[102.85967331136771,1.6515562042286291],[102.28790037095075,1.948678387240059],[101.92579991287272,2.238746619533638],[101.78497843376864,2.375964399369304],[101.78414958131034,2.3766724252216096],[101.45942735908812,2.6191724252216093],[101.45807024283582,2.6199969515610926],[101.00099089391539,2.8410571457662424],[100.72031259116558,3.11979782709667],[100.72011412681937,3.119988511701125],[99.37233634904159,4.372766289478903],[99.37119346379349,4.373656573994859],[97.62119346379349,5.506989907328193],[97.6184235598357,5.508140271683228],[95.30175689316904,6.008140271683228],[95.2983668023733,6.008165988133492],[94.7983668023733,5.908165988133493],[94.79545956817871,5.906981058341],[54.512126234845375,-20.293018941659],[54.51190494516234,-20.29316796479814],[45.71276842146294,-26.42589948131591],[32.49708781047488,-31.358864753513217],[32.496676222121856,-31.3590310136297],[25.995926325959392,-34.1887888079647],[24.834015219305527,-34.30559028263072],[21.87775260136567,-34.512248122313814],[21.876587381395996,-34.51241293014868],[20.266309603618218,-34.85769070792646],[20.26549308629953,-34.85790966953456],[19.90481445947216,-34.97455115206359],[18.37168785575706,-34.44292697306179],[-17.62513396525563,11.003060575966728],[-17.791672293431912,14.733519127115668],[-17.791672293431912,20.804849042862244],[-17.242309766691868,23.096356673340036],[-10.472243314762572,32.00980539108238],[-5.976391845438432,35.850462994307655],[-5.567343988265914,35.91343592572922],[-5.566502578736536,35.91361031588548],[-5.312480861191057,35.980093644359755],[-2.149313607754742,36.24170062879672],[-2.148230948255647,36.241862361975976],[2.8344392040968023,37.32505152553086],[8.645264514449426,37.62416058538125],[10.047323228243618,37.54751804131169],[10.047885146158213,37.5475063189395],[10.240858503573637,37.54999451409242],[11.156290818295487,37.35858593919603],[14.630959709222834,36.32535106515529],[14.631552378541489,36.32519829204803],[33.55238112532039,32.18297707393209],[33.81432125441398,32.12532252699932],[34.44712106721267,31.89218575386296],[34.44855961470708,31.891797805970832],[34.61939294804041,31.861797805970834],[34.62227371862625,31.878202194029168],[34.45217708118458,31.908072823043312],[33.819545599454,32.14114757947037],[33.818456793442394,32.141466361232645],[33.55595679344239,32.199244139010425],[33.555947621458515,32.19924615239642],[14.63541343168796,36.34140288494958],[11.160706957443832,37.374648934844714],[11.160037722513453,37.37481809318028],[10.243371055846787,37.566484759846944],[10.241559298286232,37.566660347727165],[10.047951566254165,37.564163972958845],[8.645732327311938,37.64081529202164],[8.644849680401903,37.640816695817506],[2.8329052359574574,37.34165002915084],[2.8315642815889808,37.34147097135736],[-2.1512330484493214,36.25825416047947],[-5.314575281134148,35.99663270453661],[-5.315997421263464,35.99638968411452],[-5.570303443317068,35.92983194660867],[-5.981267122845198,35.866564074270784],[-5.985409094924492,35.864665188415536],[-10.483742428257825,32.02188741063776],[-10.48496502727019,32.02059255190378],[-17.256631693936857,23.10503699634823],[-17.258098236499006,23.101941458804703],[-17.808098236499006,20.807774792138034],[-17.80832770656809,20.805833333333332],[-17.80832770656809,14.733333333333333],[-17.808319420455742,14.732961930634415],[-17.641652753789074,10.999628597301083],[-17.639861326079064,10.994829312676648],[18.360138673920936,-34.45517068732335],[18.36393834015604,-34.4578680957757],[19.901993895711595,-34.99120142910903],[19.90728469147825,-34.99125699713211],[20.270215330160887,-34.87388722636548],[21.879502512267454,-34.52882185335211],[24.835302954189885,-34.32219632213063],[24.835555169482138,-34.32217483455287],[25.998888502815472,-34.205230390108426],[26.001379333433697,-34.20458009748142],[32.50312020007196,-31.37439093653908],[45.71957885619179,-26.441135246486784],[45.72142838817099,-26.440165368535194],[54.52131893702589,-20.306908319333296],[94.80320052891958,5.892147478125083],[95.29993547898854,5.9914944681388755],[97.61341952207786,5.49218136531384],[99.36152956024033,4.36007200726577],[100.70867395418313,3.107882968378302],[100.99024296438996,2.8282577284588855],[100.99248531271974,2.8266697151055737],[101.45010060213612,2.6053503205878394],[101.77374610599823,2.36365440538542],[101.91446601067581,2.226535600630696],[101.915071256763,2.2260005511305367],[102.27812681231855,1.9351672177972035],[102.27949335529895,1.934277129104704],[102.8514367657066,1.637066361250952],[103.40342978077389,1.2349357032155004],[103.40653159372607,1.23353620351431],[103.65451175572565,1.1785829159442482],[103.72964157540368,1.129953432661744],[103.73847708106135,1.1298190655471245],[103.80597708106134,1.1706523988804578]]]);
  1. Test point-in-polygon:
console.log(turf.booleanPointInPolygon(ship, polygon));

Expected result:
true
if i use geojson.io to show the point and polygon, the point appear in polygon!

Actual result:
false

Environment:

  • Turf.js version: 7.2.0

Additional context:

  • Other Turf.js functions like pointsWithinPolygon and booleanWithin also fail to produce expected results with the provided coordinates.
  • Coordinates appear valid and correctly formatted.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions