You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The scale of Sunny-calculated dynamical structure factor intensities is should be consistent across calculation methods, following this precise specification.
In Sunny 0.5.11, the result of spin wave calculations (using SpinWaveTheory and intensities_broadened) followed this convention, whereas classical dynamics calculations (using dynamical_sampler and intensities_interpolated) did not.
Concretely, SpinWaveTheory reports intensities as $S(q,\omega)$, while classical dynamics reports intensities as $S(q,\omega) \Delta\omega$. In other words, only the SWT calculation is truly a "density" in energy space.
In Sunny 0.6, this bug is fixed. All calculation methods properly report the structure factor as a density in energy space.
Additional notes:
SpinW uses the $S(q,\omega) \Delta \omega$ convention for its broadened intensities, so to obtain quantitative agreement with Sunny 0.6, one must divide the SpinW result by a $\Delta \omega$ factor.
The results of "binned" intensities are already integrated, and this issue is not relevant to that case.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
The scale of Sunny-calculated dynamical structure factor intensities is should be consistent across calculation methods, following this precise specification.
In Sunny 0.5.11, the result of spin wave calculations (using
SpinWaveTheory
andintensities_broadened
) followed this convention, whereas classical dynamics calculations (usingdynamical_sampler
andintensities_interpolated
) did not.Concretely,$S(q,\omega)$ , while classical dynamics reports intensities as $S(q,\omega) \Delta\omega$ . In other words, only the SWT calculation is truly a "density" in energy space.
SpinWaveTheory
reports intensities asIn Sunny 0.6, this bug is fixed. All calculation methods properly report the structure factor as a density in energy space.
Additional notes:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: