You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
We would like a convenient setting for performing a brute-force translational, but not rotational, search; this can currently be achieved by hacking some flags but is not ideal.
The current options for rigid registration behave as follows:
--lsq6-simple - simply calls minctracc to perform a single rigid registration
--lsq6-centre-estimation - as above but instructs minctracc to perform a centre-of-mass alignment first
--lsq6-large-rotations - does a brute-force alignment with user-adjustable parameter sweep options (--lsq6-rotational-range and --lsq6-rotational-interval), but also (because of rotational_minctracc's default behaviour) performs a brute force translational search based on peaks in the distance transform of a bimodalT-binarized version of the source image.
As a result of this hidden distance transform functionality, --lsq6-large-rotations is actually better at finding a correct translational alignment than --lsq6-centre-estimation, leading to the situation where sometimes one can improve results by running --lsq6-large-rotations with small range/interval values (if the images are initially rotated similarly to the initial model, the default values can by chance worsen the situation, most likely to non-brain tissue which has yet to be masked at this point in the pipeline). It seems like centre-estimation should be improved to use a similar feature.
[This will also affect the upcoming ITK-based Pydpiper pipelines since antsAI and rotational_minctracc don't behave the same. More generally these options should be revised as part of an effort to improve configurability everywhere.]
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
We would like a convenient setting for performing a brute-force translational, but not rotational, search; this can currently be achieved by hacking some flags but is not ideal.
The current options for rigid registration behave as follows:
As a result of this hidden distance transform functionality, --lsq6-large-rotations is actually better at finding a correct translational alignment than --lsq6-centre-estimation, leading to the situation where sometimes one can improve results by running --lsq6-large-rotations with small range/interval values (if the images are initially rotated similarly to the initial model, the default values can by chance worsen the situation, most likely to non-brain tissue which has yet to be masked at this point in the pipeline). It seems like centre-estimation should be improved to use a similar feature.
[This will also affect the upcoming ITK-based Pydpiper pipelines since antsAI and rotational_minctracc don't behave the same. More generally these options should be revised as part of an effort to improve configurability everywhere.]
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: