Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[Enhancment] Avoiding Running outside of field on corners (turn) #2758

Open
coatsy35 opened this issue Sep 9, 2023 · 11 comments
Open

[Enhancment] Avoiding Running outside of field on corners (turn) #2758

coatsy35 opened this issue Sep 9, 2023 · 11 comments
Assignees
Labels
documentation useful stuff FS25 Will check for fs25

Comments

@coatsy35
Copy link

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

I've been thinking a lot in the last week about implements and how they handle sharp corners and the tractor going outside of the field boundary. Quite often IRL you would not start your headland run on the blue dot in my picture below, you would back up to the hedge/ditch and lower your implement and start the path further back against the hedge/ditch where the blue dashed lines shows, this has the affect's that the next pass around the headland, you do not have to pull all the way forward towards the hedge, you can stop short and the next path will complete the work. Would something like this work in CP?

Picture below, hard to translate into a drawing. Basically the tractor starts further back on the dashed line rather than at the blue circle/dot where it currently does. This would help with drills, rolls, planters, ploughs etc.... Wouldn't' be good for spreaders as they throw too far back, or combines obviously. In fact with ploughing IRL when I had completed the centre work, I would often go and "pull the corners out" first in each direction and then start my headland runs, this would mean the soil under my tractor was also ploughed in the corner

Pulling Corners Out

IMG_1348
IMG_1350
IMG_1349

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented Sep 9, 2023

Sorry, you lost me right at the second sentence, could you add something like a few numbered arrows to the diagram showing the movement of the tractor?

@coatsy35
Copy link
Author

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

Sorry, you lost me right at the second sentence, could you add something like a few numbered arrows to the diagram showing the movement of the tractor?

I will try. Should be obvious from the photo's though. You can see the effect when the next pass overlaps the previous pass to keep neat corners that are fully drilled.

@coatsy35
Copy link
Author

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

See below for a video I made to try and illustrate it. This is how you would handle sharp corners in the UK, especially where there are hedges, fences and ditches where you work from the inside out as CP does.

Most people would work from the outside in though, i.e. run alongside the hedge and then work towards the centre work if they don't have GPS or have basic GPS knowledge. Outside in tends to be people with GPS and want to show off their neatness by having no wheel marks left on the field.

https://youtu.be/46RgDlJDvjE

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented Sep 9, 2023

Oh that's great thanks. I think my confusion is that looking at your video here:
image
the area I marked is worked twice, once in the previous pass and a second time in this pass. If you work on it in this pass and pull as far forward as on this snapshot above with the implement lowered, than how is that different from what CP does now?

@coatsy35
Copy link
Author

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

Oh that's great thanks. I think my confusion is that looking at your video here: image the area I marked is worked twice, once in the previous pass and a second time in this pass. If you work on it in this pass and pull as far forward as on this snapshot above with the implement lowered, than how is that different from what CP does now?

It would man you tractor could stop short of the field boundary in front of it, so less risk of running into a tree or snagging on something that stops the tractor driving far enough forward to complete the pass (I often come back to a field to find a tractor unable to drive far enough forward to complete the pass with long implements such as a trailed drill or plough and they are stuck).

It's just an idea and food for thought.

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented Sep 9, 2023

Ok, I think I get it now, it definitely makes sense for implements that are long but relatively narrow so the tractor + implement is longer than the working width.

Moving to the Courseplay repo as this is a turn maneuver change, not a generator issue.

@pvaiko pvaiko transferred this issue from Courseplay/CourseGenerator Sep 9, 2023
@pvaiko pvaiko self-assigned this Sep 9, 2023
@pvaiko pvaiko added the enhancement New feature or request label Sep 9, 2023
@coatsy35
Copy link
Author

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

Ok, I think I get it now, it definitely makes sense for implements that are long but relatively narrow so the tractor + implement is longer than the working width.

Moving to the Courseplay repo as this is a turn maneuver change, not a generator issue.

Yes that's it.

@Tensuko
Copy link
Contributor

Tensuko commented Sep 9, 2023

Uhm, we kind of do this already, as long as the work width is bigger then the lenght of the vehicle.

@coatsy35
Copy link
Author

coatsy35 commented Sep 9, 2023

Uhm, we kind of do this already, as long as the work width is bigger then the length of the vehicle.

Yes it does. But a lot of implements are longer than the width unfortunately, I see it with the Kuhn Merge Max and other large trailed windrowers,, the Krone Big M Mower, most trailed mowers like the Kongskilde GXT13005P comes to mind and KV 4140L, large square balers, most ploughs, and root harvesters as you already know.

Perhaps something can be done in the future.

@Tensuko
Copy link
Contributor

Tensuko commented Sep 10, 2023

Can you make a drawing with arrows how the turn should look like?

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented Sep 10, 2023

He did already, explained to me also there's a video. I know what to do.

@Tensuko Tensuko changed the title Avoiding Running outside of field on corners [Enhancment] Avoiding Running outside of field on corners (turn) May 7, 2024
@Tensuko Tensuko added the documentation useful stuff label Jun 27, 2024
@Tensuko Tensuko removed the enhancement New feature or request label Oct 4, 2024
@Tensuko Tensuko added the FS25 Will check for fs25 label Oct 20, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
documentation useful stuff FS25 Will check for fs25
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants